TARDIS File 05-07: Amy’s Choice
The Big Idea: The Doctor visits Rory and a very pregnant Amy five years in the future, but everything isn’t as it seems and a mysterious figure called the Dream Lord offers Amy a choice.
What’s So Great
- Simon Nye’s script may not be for everyone, but it’s definitely full of great one-liners and invention, and director Catherine Morshead is a perfect match to move it along. Witness the scene transition when the Dream Lord says, “You know the Doctor, he’s Mr. Cool,” and the scene cuts to Matt Smith doing a brilliantly timed “silly walk” down the road.
- Creepy old pensioners inhabited by aliens make an effective menace. There are wonderful little homages to Night of the Living Dead, particularly the scene where the old folks are shuffling across a field of sheep, or when Rory has to whack a former patient with a piece of wood.
- Toby Jones is fantastic as the Dream Lord, echoing the Doctor’s eccentricities, wit and cadences, but stripping them of their charm, enthusiasm and warmth.
- The Doctor drives a VW van. How cool is that. I would have been happy just seeing a VW van, but the Doctor actually drives it!
- Watching the episode a second time, knowing what you know, not being distracted by your suspicion that Valeyard might just show up, and spotting all the clues.
Some Quick Bits of Trivia: Simon Nye who penned the episode is probably best known as co-creator/writer of the popular 1990’s ITV/BBC situation comedy Men Behaving Badly. Nick Hobbs, who who plays Mr Nainby previously played Aggedor in the third Doctor adventures The Curse of Peladon and The Monster of Peladon.
Things to Geek Out About:
- The Doctor reveals that he threw the TARDIS manual into a supernova (the manual was first shown being disdained by the Doctor in the classic series story The Pirate Planet)
- The Dream Lord taunts Amy with the fact that she isn’t that important to Doctor because she doesn’t know his name. The Doctor’s true name has never been revealed in the programme’s history, but it was inferred that he revealed it to River Song at some point in the future (as evidenced in The Forest of the Dead).
- The Doctor’s relationship with Elizabeth I is referenced yet again by the Dream Lord
Not to Complain, But… The Doctor proclaiming that Amy and Rory have no darkness in them is a little trite, and belies Amy’s earlier action of driving herself, the Doctor and her unborn child into a wall (regardless of how distraught she is over Rory’s death it’s a rash and selfish decision). And while the plot device of having the Doctor, Amy and Rory collapsing into sleep is a necessary one, it wears out its welcome by the end of the episode.
All things considered: Exploring the Doctor’s dark side is tricky. Back before companion Barbara Wright humanized the first Doctor, William Hartnell played the role as decidedly prickly and anti-heroic. The Edge of Destruction used plot a device not unlike Amy’s Choice to delve a little further into that darkness. Over the years subsequent production teams have flirted with the Doctor’s shadow aspects through the sixth Doctor’s more alien side, the bizarre revelation in that same era that the Valeyard was in fact an amalgam of the Doctor’s darker side, through to the seventh Doctor’s puppet master persona and onto Russell T Davies’ exploration of a battle scarred Doctor culminating in what was probably the Doctor’s darkest onscreen moment at the end of The Waters of Mars.
The challenge is that most of the audience wants to see the Doctor acting heroic. Thus with rare exception an external factor has to be introduced into the narrative: in this case a little “exotic pollen” in the TARDIS gears and a loopy dream narrative, with the Dream Lord (perhaps not so subtly in retrospect) standing in for the Doctor. If one strips down Amy’s Choice to it’s a core, it’s a classic three hander psycho drama (much like the aforementioned The Edge of Destruction) with some fantasy setting elements stirred in for fun and diversion.
But of course the focus of the episode is Amy and probably the most important scenes for Karen Gillan come when she’s sitting with the Dream Lord trying to assert her importance to the Doctor, and later when she loses Rory and decides she doesn’t want to live in a world without him. It’s a complicated scenario and I think in the end it doesn’t come down to whether you think the denouement was logical, but whether you buy Gillan’s performance.
Does it work? Mostly yes, thanks to Simon Nye’s funny (albeit at times a bit sitcom-y) and well paced script. Yes, it feels like a familiar sci-fi/fantasy trope, but as ever with Doctor Who it’s the journey. And Arthur Darvill’s quiet desperation at having to compete with Amy’s new world, and the sadness with which he holds onto to his quiet village life is very poignant and affecting. The Doctor is essentially travelling with two people in love and if you look closely it’s very interesting.
Ultimately the episode will probably disappoint those fans who are waiting for the plot to pay off with some mind bending twist, but there are subtler pleasures for those who find their Who quirkier little places.
Lines of the Week: “Ohhh my boys… my poncho boys… If we’re going to die, let’s die looking like a Peruvian folk band.”
TARDIS File prepared by Scott Clarke
In our final issue : Enlightenment reviews the anniversary celebrations! Plus…
- Michael Wisher and Philip Hinchcliffe interviewed
- The recovered Troughton episodes
- News and reviews
Their Secrets Revealed : The final reviews for Season 2013! Plus, in this last print issue of Enlightenment before the all-digital era begins…
- Re-evaluating recovered episodes—you know, hypothetically…
- The Gazetteer of Doom
- News and reviews
Gold represents something long-lasting, something untarnished and unaffected by the passage of time. Myth Makers Presents: Golden Years celebrates the timeless elements of Doctor Who that have appealed to the show’s followers for half a century. Celebrating 50 years of Doctor Who with DWIN’s fiction anthology, Myth Makers!
Enlightenment will be switching to a digital only publication and membership fees will be ending. Find out more about this important change
Who will be the next Doctor? Find out LIVE on SPACE this Sunday at 2pm Eastern, 11am Pacific.
- And we’re back!
- Happy 53rd Anniversary
- Top of the Class?
- Fan Myth RIP #3 - Celebrity Guest Casting is and was “bad” for Doctor Who
- Animated Curiosity
- Fan Myth RIP #2 - William Hartnell Was Playing Himself
- Fan Myth RIP #1 - Continuity Kills
- Head of the Class
- The Companion Departures Extra: Clara Oswald
- The Companion Departures - #1: Adric
- The Companion Departures - #2: Jo Grant
- The Companion Departures - #3: Victoria Waterfield
- The Companion Departures - #4: Romana
- The Companion Departures - #5: Perpugiliam (Peri) Brown