TARDIS File 06-11: The God Complex
The Big Idea: Somewhere in space, there’s a fleabitten 1980s hotel, and one of its many rooms contains your darkest fear. There’s no way out and there’s a monster roaming the corridors. And it’s going to get you eventually, whoever you are—even if you’re the Doctor. Believe it.
What’s So Great…
- The occasionally bizarre and inexplicable nature of the fears in each room highlights how personal they are to each individual.
- The character of Gibbis is masterfully written and played, with just the right balance of comedy, pathos, and creepiness.
- The room containing the eleventh Doctor’s fear is number 11, and the room containing Amy’s fear is number 7, the age she was when she first met the Doctor.
- The Doctor’s shattering realisation that his attempts to protect the hotel’s victims are exactly what’s been killing them—and the fact that the episode doesn’t explicitly reveal that he’s just lost his faith in himself.
Some Quick Bits of Trivia… David Walliams, who played Gibbis, is better known as one of the team behind Little Britain, and previously appeared in the Doctor Who audio play Phantasmagoria (and performed with Mark Gatiss the comedy sketches in the 1999 Doctor Who Night on the BBC: The Pitch of Fear, The Web of Caves and The Kidnappers). Writer Toby Whithouse has scripted School Reunion and The Vampires of Venice, and created the series Being Human and No Angels (both of which featured medical professionals as characters). And Daffyd Emyr, the cruel PE teacher, previously appeared as a Torchwood agent in the TARDISode for Army of Ghosts.
Things to Geek Out About…
- Caitlin Blackwood is back as young Amelia Pond for the second time this season.
- Former victims of the hotel include a Sontaran officer named Commander Halke; a Judoon; and Novice Prin, a Sister of Plenitude from New Earth. (Since New Earth existed in the year 5 billion but Howie and Rita appear to be from contemporary 21st-century Earth, this would imply either that the Sisters of Plenitude are a very, very long-lasting order or that the hotel had time-travel capabilities.)
- The minotaur creature is described as a “distant cousin” of the Nimon from The Horns of Nimon; perhaps they’re related in the same way as Planet of the Ood revealed the Ood are related to the Sensorites?
- The Doctor has had to destroy his companion’s faith in him to save her before, in The Curse of Fenric.
- In an appropriate reuse of old music cues, the music as Amy watches the Doctor leave her in the end is the same music used in The Eleventh Hour as the Doctor leaves young Amelia. And hey, he did eventually come back that time…
- The Doctor produces a Rubik’s Cube from his pockets while describing the hotel as being from the 1980s. Is this the same cube he was playing with in George’s bedroom in Night Terrors?
- Rory mentioned his sadistic PE teacher in The Doctor’s Wife, and in Night Terrors, the Doctor intimated having a fear of clowns. Having said that, neither the cruel PE teacher nor the clown appeared to be in Rory or the Doctor’s respective rooms in this episode.
- We don’t see what’s in the Doctor’s room, but we do hear the TARDIS Cloister Bell, signaling imminent disaster since Logopolis
Did You Notice… There were few explicit arc references in this episode, apart from Amy asking the Doctor to tell her daughter to visit when he next bumps into her, but… well, see the analysis below. Also, when the hotel’s holographic framework folds up at the climax, it does so in a way similar to the Teselactor from Let’s Kill Hitler. Is there a relationship between this hotel, which was set up to punish the Minotaur, and the Teselactor’s mission to punish history’s greatest war criminals? More importantly, who or what did the Doctor see and recognise inside his own room, and why was the TARDIS cloister bell tolling in the background when he saw it?
Not to Complain, But… Deleted Scene Alert: the Doctor claims that Rory keeps being shown a way out, even though Rory has only seen one actual exit on-screen and we never saw him tell the Doctor about it. Also, some of the music is quite inappropriately whimsical and lighthearted for the situations in which the Doctor finds himself, such as searching the hallways for the body of a man he’s failed to save from the Minotaur.
All Things Considered… So there’s this thing, this implacable force, and you know that it’s going to kill you. More than just kill you, it’s going to suck out the very spark of your life—all your hopes and dreams, everything that keeps you going—until you finally die just from not being alive any more. And your faith, the one thing you turn to in your darkest hour, isn’t doing anything to stop it. It’s always there and it’s always going to be there, and eventually, you just give in to it. You not only accept your fate, you begin to look forward to it, even beg for it. It’s just so much easier not to fight it, and in fact, when you stop, the blessed relief of giving up feels like euphoria. Your friends don’t understand, but that’s okay, they’ve got their own lives to live and this isn’t about them; you’re just going to go now, and leave them to get on with things. And when it finally comes for you, when you finally give yourself up to it, you can finally relax into knowing that it’s all over, and it feels… so… good.
Yeah. Fans of classic Doctor Who have often considered themselves to be depressed about the existence of the Nimon, but they probably never imagined turning that into an allegory. The Minotaur isn’t just a monster, it’s the personification of giving up in the face of impossible odds; this plays out even in tiny details like Gibbis’s school motto, “Resistance is exhausting,” which sounds like a joke until you actually think about what it means as a philosophy. It’s not a perfect allegory, and it gets somewhat muddled with the religious imagery (one of the Doctor’s first acts upon arriving is to chow down on an apple, and he later can’t resist his intense curiosity about looking into the face of danger)—but upon consideration, that probably makes the episode more worthy of discussion than a simple point-to-point correspondence would have been.
Think about this: if the Minotaur is getting to Amy through her faith in the Doctor, and if that’s meant to be a metaphor for how depression destroys our will to live, then why does destroying that faith destroy the monster instead of Amy? There’s probably an argument to be made that, rather than destroying the thing that makes Amy’s life worth living, the Doctor is instead telling Amy to see that thing as the childish illusion it is, and to move on to something real. But considering that at least one of the character’s faiths was based in religion, this interpretation is getting into controversial territory that’s probably beyond the scope of this particular review. Not to mention that, taken to the logical extreme, it’s suggesting that we should stop watching this program and go do something better with our lives.
In the end, though, it’s doing nothing of the sort. The Doctor tries to save the goldfish in the hotel’s barbershop, only to deliver it into the hands of Gibbis, who eats it—just as his attempts to protect the people in the hotel end up delivering them to the thing that will devour them. That parallel should alert us to another, more significant one. Rita is a sharp, intelligent person who dies because she turns her back on the people trying to save her and instead embraces her fate alone. She goes to her end gladly, telling herself that she’s doing it to stop her friends from trying to prevent the inevitable and dying in her place. And that’s exactly what the Doctor does at the end of this episode. In Night Terrors, the final shot was of the Doctor’s death date on the TARDIS scanner—but there are no such explicit arc references in this episode. That’s because this entire episode is the memento mori. At the end, the Doctor realises that in describing the Minotaur’s death wish, he’s described himself—and his reaction is to take Amy and Rory “back home” and go off on his own. He’s turning his back on his friends and embracing his fate alone, telling himself that he’s doing it to stop them from trying to prevent the inevitable and dying in his place.
Despite the music’s attempts to convince us that we’re watching another of the Doctor’s wacky space adventures, we’re seeing something much deeper and darker here. The Doctor’s no longer trying to outrun his fate, he’s beginning to embrace it, and that’s exactly what threatens to make it inevitable. The Doctor really is falling further than ever before. Let’s hope that he rises so much higher.
Line of the Week: “I’m not a hero. I really am just a madman in a box. And it’s time we saw each other as we really are.”
TARDIS File prepared by Cameron Dixon
Please comment on the Doctor Who Blog!
Who Party Toronto Presents:
An Afternoon With Gary Russell
Sunday June 9th, 2013 from noon until 6:00pm
Paupers Pub (second floor), 539 Bloor Street W.
Cost: $15 for the afternoon
On Sunday June 9th, 2013 join The Doctor Who Information Network and Who Party Toronto for An Afternoon With Gary Russell on the second floor of Paupers Pub at 539 Bloor Street West.
The afternoon will feature a Q&A session with our guest Doctor Who writer and Script Editor Gary Russell as well as a live video commentary of a Doctor Who episode that he worked on, an autograph session, a trivia competition and an afternoon of discussions and socializing with other Doctor Who fans.
The Snowmen Cometh (Christmas Special Reviewed!) : The 2012 Christmas special gets a look-over! Plus…
- Can good Doctor Who be bad television, and vice versa?
- Robots with human souls
- News and reviews
It has been announced that the final eight episodes of Series Seven of Doctor Who will be airing on BBC1, SPACE and BBC America starting on Saturday March 30th, 2013.
Archaeology Tomorrow (Season Reviews and Benny’s 20th!) : The 2012 season review issue, and the importance of being Bernice Surprise Summerfield! Plus…
- Why Doctor Who is Steampunk
- Where are the new series’ truly iconic villains?
- News and reviews
The seventh series of Doctor Who comes to our screens on September 1 at 9 pm on SPACE!
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 19 - 1981
- Silver Upgrade
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 18 - 1980
- Queen Crimson
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 17 - 1979
- Come Along If You Dare
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 16 - 1978
- Don’t Hide Your Feelings
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 15 - 1977
- Ice, Ice, Very Nice
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 14 - 1976
- The Ring of Clara
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 13 - 1975
- Wi-Fi Sci-Fi
- 50 Glorious Years: Episode 12 - 1974